Sunday, 14 December 2014

Is homosexuality a lifestyle choice or is it determined at birth?

I had to write a two page paper on this topic and I'd just like to share my views.

Dictionary.com defines homosexuality as sexual desire or behavior directed toward a person or persons of one's own sex.” This means that a person would not only have the desire, but as postulated by the definition, a homosexual will have sexual behavior or activities with a person of their own sex. Clearly, a person cannot be born like this.
The majority of homosexuals believe they were born "gay” because this belief often supplies them with comfort, relieving them of any responsibility to change. This belief is also used to justify the actions of homosexuals. However, there is no solid scientific evidence that people are born homosexual. The overwhelming majority of gay people are completely normal genetically. They are fully male or female.
In the article “This is the way God Made Me ” Harrub et al suggested that “Skin color and other genetic traits can be traced through inheritance patterns and simple Mendelian genetics.  Homosexuals are identified not by a trait or a gene, but rather by their actions.  Without the action, they would be indistinguishable from all other people.  It is only when they alter their behavior that they become a group that is recognized as being different.
The article also continues to say that “it is not scientifically accurate to refer to a “gay gene” as the causative agent in homosexuality.  The available evidence clearly establishes that no such gene has been identified.  Additionally, evidence exists which documents that homosexuals can change their sexual orientation.
If even the alleged “gay gene” existed, it cannot account for homosexual behavior completely. Sarah Knapton (2014) indicated that “Homosexuality is only partly genetic with sexuality mostly based on environmental and social factors, scientists believe. A study found that, while gay men shared similar genetic make-up, it only accounted for 40 per cent of the chance of a man being homosexual.” This means that there is a 60 percent chance that a man with the “gay gene” will not be homosexual. In fact the scientist that found the alleged “gay genes” cannot give account for homosexual behavior in females. There is no “gay genes” found in females. So how then, do females become homosexual or “lesbian?” What is responsible for homosexuality is females?

Sarah Knapton (2014) also quoted that “environmental factors were likely to have the biggest impact on homosexuality…Environment means anything that is not in our DNA at birth, and that includes a lot of stuff that is not social.”

Homosexuality may have some genetic influences, but like all other genetic traits, or influences, having them is not really a problem, but rather acting on them. For example, a person can have the genetic trait of athletic abilities, that person may have the desire to become athletic, but the desire in itself does not make that person athletic. To become athletic, the person must choose to perform athletic activities.  

Having a natural or intrinsic sexual desire cannot completely justify a person’s sexual orientation. Whether or not someone is naturally oriented to be romantically and sexually attracted to people of the same gender does not mean that it is automatically morally acceptable or should be their way of life. If a person's natural predisposition toward same-sex attraction means that it is normal "for them" and thereby acceptable, then we run into problems. What do we do with people who are naturally oriented towards being attracted to children, i.e., pedophilia? Is it morally wrong? Should we allow them to act on their intrinsic sexual desire? You see, if we say that a "natural" orientation in sexuality should automatically be accepted because it is what is "natural" to a person, then the same logic could be used to support the idea that pedophilia--which people also claim is natural for them--is also acceptable. Thus, Homosexuality is a lifestyle choice and cannot be determined by birth.